Pak. J. Bot., 42(1): 661-678, 2010.
M. KABIR, M. ZAFAR IQBAL, Z.R. FAROOQI AND M. SHAFIQ
Department of Botany, University of Karachi
Karachi, 75270, Pakistan
Abstract
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Results
A. fruticosum showed its leading presence class V. P. juliflora, C. trilocularis and T. terrestris attained the presence class IV. A. javanica, A. viridis, S. holosericea, L. nudicaulis, C. depressus and Salvadora sp., had the constancy class III. Whereas, Z. simplex, S. fruticosa, C. glomeratus, C. cretica, C. viscosa, C. procera, B. sindica, D. muricata, C. decidua, A. pakistanicum and R. pulverulenta showed the presence class II. Whereas, species showed the lowest presence class I. P. juliflora, A. fruticosum, C. trilocularis, A. javanica, A. viridis and C. viscoasa occurred as first leading dominant in association with second and third dominant species. There are 24 species viz., P. jailor, A. fruticosum, C. trichorus, A. javanica, A. viridis, S. holosericea, Z. simplex, S. fruticosa, C. depressus, C. cretica, C. viscose, C. procera, F. indica, C. barbata, T. terrestriss, L. nudicaulis, B. sindica, Salvadora sp., S. albicaule, C. decidua, A. sessilis, A. pakistanicum, H. recurvum and M. lotoides which occurred as first, second or third leading dominant species in studied areas.
The community descriptions in relation to soil characteristics influenced by the industrial activities are described as follows:
1. Prosopis juliflora community: P. juliflora is considered as aggressive and tolerant species. In industrial area it occurred in 21 stands out of 30 stands and leads its dominance in 5 stands. This community preferred to grow on high percentage of sand (61.36%), silt (13.64%) and clay particles (24.97%). The community preferred sandy clay loam type soil. Better water holding capacity of soil (25.36%), bulk density (1.47 g-cc), porosity (43.70%), Calcium carbonate (14.68%), pH (7.26), chloride (311 mg-L), organic matter (3.48%), total organic carbon (2.18 g) were recorded here with lowest available sulfur contents (80.62 µg-g), moderate electrical conductivity (7.15 dS-cm), total dissolved salt (5.30 mg-L), exchangeable sodium (442 ppm) and potassium (185 ppm).
2. Abutilon fruticosum community: A. fruticosum occurred in 25 stands out of 30 stands and leads its first dominance position in four stands. It was recorded in moderate percentage of sand (52.46%), silt (23.00%) and clay (24.54%), respectively. This community preferred to grow on sandy clay loam type soil which had moderate water holding capacity (26.26%), bulk density (1.43 g-cc), porosity (46.88), CaCO3 (18.61%), pH (7.15), chlorides (188.8 mg-L) and total organic carbon (2.13 g). While low amount of organic matter (3.95%), available sulfur contents (96.57 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (153 ppm) and potassium (136 ppm), electrical conductivity (6.2 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (3.15 mg-L) were found in industrial areas soil in which this community was flourishing.
3. Zygophyllum simplex community: Z. simplex occurred in 10 stands in study area while in 3 stands it occurs as a first leading dominant species. Community is supported by higher percentage of total sand (50.06%) with low amount of silt (18.07%) and highest percentage of clay particles (31.86%). This community preferred sandy clay loam. Water holding capacity of soil of this community was slightly high (28.15%) with high exchangeable sodium (604 ppm), moderate exchangeable potassium (156 ppm), bulk density (1.43 g-cc) and porosity (46.00%). The soil samples of the community contained lowest CaCO3 (7.15%), with acidic pH (6.91), chloride (360 mg-L), organic matter (3.20%) total organic carbon (1.85 g), available sulfur (106.25 µg-g), electrical conductivity (9.0 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (6.70 mg-L).
4. Aerva javanica community: This community occurs in 15 stands while dominating in 4 stands. It community is supported by high percentage of total sand (57.30%) with more or less equal amount of silt (21.83%) and clay particles (20.78%), preferred to grow on sandy clay loam. Water holding capacity of soil of this community was slightly high (27.30%) with total organic carbon (2.77 g). Soil bulk density and porosity were 1.40 g-cc and 46.75%, respectively. The soil of this community contained low CaCO3 (16.68%), pH (7.18), chloride (195 mg-L), organic matter (4.37%), available sulfur (86.30 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (83 ppm) and potassium (88 ppm), electrical conductivity (2.15 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (1.65 mg-L).
5. Corchorus trilocularis community: It is recorded in 20 stands in which 2 stands it occurred as leading dominant. This community had better percentage of sand (56.80) and silt (16.00%) with 27.10% clay. This community preferred to grow on sandy clay loam. Water holding capacity of soil of this community was slightly high (25.10%) with moderate exchangeable potassium (198ppm). Soil bulk density and porosity were 1.49g-cc and 43.80%, respectively. The polluted soil of industrial sites contained low CaCO3 (19.30%), pH (7.25), chloride (130 mg-L), organic matter (3.15%), total organic carbon (1.83 g), available sulfur (86.30 µg-g), exchangeable Sodium (98ppm), electrical conductivity (1.4 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (1.10 mg-L).
6. Suaeda fruticosa community: This community occurs in 8 stands while dominating in 2 stands. Soil characteristics with relation to S. fruticosa plant community indicated that this community is well growing in the industrial area polluted soil sandy clay loam, with high percentage sand (48.30%) and low silt (28.68%) and high clay (22.97%). Maximum water holding capacity was found high (24.91%) with high total organic carbon (3.37 g) and exchangeable sodium (1320 ppm) in polluted soil of this community. Low bulk density (1.37g-cc) and porosity (48.37%) were found in this community. Low calcium carbonate (11.75%), soil pH (6.49) and chloride (mg-L) were recorded in the soil. Moderate percentage of organic matter (5.85), and exchangeable potassium (108 ppm), low available sulfur contents (104.35 µg-g), high electrical conductivity (25.85 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (19.05 mg-L) were determined in this community.
7. Cressa cretica community: This community occurs in 8 stands while dominating in 2 stands. Soil characteristics indicated that this community is well growing in industrial area polluted soil with high percentage of sand (41.12%), as compared to silt (32.43%) and clay (26.45%). This community preferred to grow on sandy clay loam. Maximum water holding capacity (28.96 %), bulk density (1.35 g-cc), porosity (48.75%), CaCO3 (22.22%), exchangeable potassium (96 ppm) and pH (7.2) were recorded in soil of this community. These soil also contained 60.00 mg-L chloride with high organic matter (5.70%), total organic carbon (3.30 g), available sulfur (85.65 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (252 ppm), electrical conductivity (17.05 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (12.55 mg-L).
8. Amaranthus viridis community: Sandy clay loam soils showed 57.30% sand, 15.50% silt and 27.2% clay with maximum water holding capacity, bulk density and porosity were 26.45%, 1.43 g-cc and 46.00%, respectively with soil pH 6.84. Some other soil characteristics such as chlorides (425.00 mg-L), organic matter (5.47%) total organic carbon (3.18 g), available sulfur (44.37 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (340 ppm) and potassium (300 ppm), were quite high with moderate electrical conductivity (7.20 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (5.35 mg-L).
9. Fagonia indica community: This species was found in sandy loam with moderate percentage of sand (52.37%), silt (22.75%) and clay (24.88%) in industrial soil samples. Maximum water holding capacity (25.01%), bulk density (1.48 g-cc), porosity (44.25%), CaCO3 (15.37%) and pH (6.94) were recorded. Some other soil characteristics such as chlorides (252.50 mg-L), organic matter (3.35%), total organic carbon (1.95 g), available sulfur (52.50 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (366 ppm) and potassium (156 ppm), electrical conductivity (4.40 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (3.25 mg-L) were also recorded in this community.
10. Senna holosericea community: Total percentage of sand, silt and clay was 61.80%, 13.56% and 25.20%, sandy clay loam respectively in S. holosericea community. Maximum water holding capacity, bulk density and porosity were 27.23%, 1.45 g-cc and 45.50%, respectively. Some other soil characteristics such as soil pH 7.31, chlorides (245.00 mg-L), organic matter (3.35%), total organic carbon (1.94), available sulfur (55.00 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (200 ppm) and potassium (200 ppm), were quite high with low electrical conductivity (3.20 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (2.40 mg-L).
11. Corchorus depressus community: This community showed its distribution in sandy clay loam with high percentage of sand (69.44%), low silt (11.00%) and clay (19.56%) particles. Low water holding capacity (23.91), bulk density (1.54 g-cc) and high porosity (42.05%) were found in this community. High calcium carbonate (19.55%) and organic matter (3.55%), total organic carbon (2.06 g) were recoded. Alkaline soil pH (7.65) moderate chloride (140.00 mg-L), exchangeable sodium (120 ppm) and potassium (80 ppm) were recorded in the community. High available sulfur contents (125 µg-g) were determined for this community with very low electrical conductivity (0.80 dS -cm) and total dissolved salt (0.60 mg-L).
12. Cleome viscosa community: Total percentage of sand, silt and clay for this community was 48.30%, 29.00% and 22.70%, sandy clay loam respectively. Maximum water holding capacity (26.71%), bulk density (1.42 g-cc) and porosity (46.50%) were recorded. Soil pH (7.64), calcium carbonate (15.30%), organic matter (5.25%), total organic carbon (2.47 g), chlorides (125.00 mg-L), available sulfur (122.50 µg-g), exchangeable potassium (144 ppm) were found high with very low electrical conductivity (0.90 dS-cm), exchangeable sodium (76 ppm) and total dissolved salt (0.70 mg-L) in soil of studied areas.
13. Calotropis procera community: This species showed its distribution in sandy loam type soil. High percentage of sand (59.80%), low silt (13.00%) and clay (27.20%) were recorded. This community had high maximum water holding capacity (26.15%), bulk density (1.45 g-cc), porosity (45.00%), CaCO3 (18.10%), pH (7.50) and exchangeable potassium (262 ppm). The other important soil characteristics such as low chlorides (145.00 mg-L) and organic matter (2.00%), moderate available sulfur (118.75 µg-g) and total organic carbon (1.61 g) were also recorded with low electrical conductivity (1.20 dS-cm), total dissolved salt (0.90 mg-L) and exchangeable sodium (54 ppm).
14. Mollugo lotoides community: This species preferred to grow in sandy clay loam type soil. High percentage of sand (54.80%), and low silt (21.50%) and clay (23.70%) were found in the soil of M. lotoides community. This community had high maximum water holding capacity (31.59%), bulk density (1.27 g-cc), porosity (51.50%), CaCO3 (18.40%) and exchangeable potassium (258 ppm). The other important soil characteristics such as acidic soil pH (6.82), high chlorides (315.00 mg-L), organic matter (4.05%), total organic carbon (2.35 g), moderate available sulfur (36.25 µg-g), exchangeable sodium (280 ppm), electrical conductivity (4.90 dS-cm) and total dissolved salt (3.60 mg-L) were recorded in soil of this community.
15. Chloris barbata community: This species occurred in five stands in which appeared first leading dominant in one stand. It is supported by higher percentage of total sand (64.80%) with low silt (13.00%) and high clay (22.20%) particles. This community preferred to grow on sandy clay loam. Water holding capacity in soil of the community was slightly high (33.36%). Low bulk density (1.33 g-cc), porosity (27.00%), CaCO3 (19.50%), exchangeable potassium (36 ppm) with moderate exchangeable sodium (240 ppm) were found in soil of this community. The soil contained alkaline pH (7.11), high chloride (445 mg-L), organic matter (6.40%) total organic carbon (3.71 g), available sulfur (120.00 µg-g) with 4.50 dS-cm electrical conductivity and 3.30 mg-L total dissolved salt.
Discussion
Plant communities around the industrial sites were composed on diverse type of plant species. The vegetation is predominately composed of halophytes, xerophytes and disturbed species. The vegetation was mostly dominated by P. juliflora, A. fruticosum, A. javanica, S. fruticosa, F. indica, S. holosericea and C. procera as leading dominant in the study areas. A. javanica in association with other disturbed species formed a prominent community, similar to the communities which were found around the cement factories of Karachi (Iqbal et al., 2001). An appreciable amount of calcium carbonate, poor amount of organic matter is a characteristics feature of arid zone soils (Aubert, 1960). Plants directly depend on soil characteristics and climatic factors for their growth and development. Singh (1986) observed that in those plant communities which had a higher percentage of soil organic matter, the water holding capacity of soil was consequently increased due to the colloidal nature of the organic matter. Pakistani soils are extremely low in organic matter (Ladha et al., 1996; Zia et al., 1998; Bhatti, 1999; Aslam et al., 2000). Industrial soils contained appreciable water holding capacity due to porosity of soil as soil pores can attain more water. Chloride and sulphur contents were also found more in industrial soil as compared to non-industrial soil which caused reduction in various growth variables in industrial soils. High amount of available sulfate reduces the plant growth and absorbed sulphur in the form of sulphate which might be due to industrial emission of SO2. Exposure to SO2 caused notable and significant reduction in the dry matter accumulation and yield of Lolium perenne L. cv. S23 (Ashenden & Mansfield, 1977; Bell et al., 1979). Chemical balance of inorganic elements in the living organism is a basic condition for their proper growth and development (Markert, 1990). The plants under stress conditions are most likely to be adversely affected by high level of heavy metals. Excessive amount of heavy metals usually caused reduction in plant growth (Prodgers & Inskeep, 1981). Further more, morphology of bean plants was also influenced by the presence of metals; the color of plants was shown to turn yellow, which in turn affected photosynthesis (Azmat et al., 2005). The effects of toxic substances on plants are dependent on the amount of toxic substance taken up from a given environment. The toxicity of some metals may be so high that plant growth is retarded before large quantities of an element can be translocated (Haghiri, 1973). Based on low plant biodiversity in polluted areas, plant communities viz., P. juliflora, A. fruticosum, A. javanica, S. fruticosa, F. indica, S. holosericea and C. procera indicating their wide range of ecological adaptation. Soil type with respect to total percentage of sand, silt and clay is a key factor for distributions of plant communities. The vegetation of Sindh Industrial Trading Estates of Karachi was mostly halophytic and disturbed which is indicated by the community of S. fruticosa and C. cretica. Soil analysis indicated that industrial soil was sandy in nature with low percentage of organic matter while bulk density of industrial area soil was high with less porosity and maximum water holding capacity. Calcium carbonate was high in industrial soil while pH ranges from acidic to basis with high chlorides. Phytosociologial and soil studies helps us in understanding the formation of plant communities. Such relationships are important because generally, when we relate each other to underlying factors a better picture of the relationships results. The challenges to save plant communities from the industrial disturbance are not new. The distribution of vegetation more closely resemble to the changes in the soil characteristics. Disturbance in the habitat types of the flora of the region makes it unproductive and produced negative impact on the ecosystem. Analysis of industrial area soil and vegetation showed variation due to discharge of various types of pollutants. The retention and presence of these pollutants in and surrounding the industries greatly decrease the habitat potential for flora of the region. The efforts and contribution from commercial, industrial and institutional sectors for the support of the flora located in and around these industrial units has the fruitful potential. It is concluded that industrialization activities strongly influenced the plant communities. Numbers of species in some plant communities had increased while in others were unable to survive Uzair et al., (2009) concluded the same findings at Dhabaji industrial area. Managing the stable environment for habitat of such plant species requires a diverse set of goals. One strategy would be to follow the selection of the plant species from the phytosociological studies that are known to having better importance value indices. Plantation in such disturbed areas is often helpful in removing the hazards materials from the environment. Concern about all flora of the region such as grasses, herbs and shrubs in the industrial areas needs proper attention. Eight communities preferred to grow on sandy loam type’s soil. Whereas, 22 communities occurred on sandy clay loam soil. The soils of the industrial area were contaminated by pollutants. Heavy metal uptake has been found to have detrimental effects on plant growth or fitness (Giblin et al., 1980; Suntonvongsagul et al., 2007). Several scientists noted the capacity of salt marshes plants to take and absorb some quantity of heavy metals as P. australis could take up and store a variety of metals as a phytoremediator of Hg, Mg, and Cr contamination (Williams et al., 1994; Windham et al., 2001). There is a need to developed green spaces within and around the industrial areas for the formation of better environmental conditions. To overcome the hazardous effects of toxic pollutants released from the industries in future our first priority must be a maintaining a healthy environment. An attempt has been made to focus on soil characteristics of the polluted areas and plant communities growing in that area. The conclusion which could be drawn from this study is that all the vegetation types which were observed around SITE area of Karachi were disturbed by human activities, mainly through the release of pollutants from different industries. If the haphazard population growth and the construction of new industrial structure go on then probably there would be more vegetation changes in near future.
References
Ahmed, M.,
S.A. Qadir and S.S. Shoukat. 1978.
Multivariate approaches to the analysis of vegetational environmental
complex of Gharo, Dhabeji and Manghopir industrial areas. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 10: 31-51.
Allen, S.E.,
M.H. Grimshaw, J.A. Parkinson and C. Quarmby. 1974. Chemical Analysis of
Ecological Materials. In:(Ed.): S.E. Allen. Blackwell Scientific Publications,
Oxford London, Edinburg, Melbourne, pp. 386.
Ashenden,
T.W. and T.A. Mansfield. 1977. Influence of wind speed on the sensitivity of
rye grass to SO2. Journal of
Experimental Botany, 28: 729-735.
Aslam, M.,
I.A. Mahmood, T. Sultan and S. Ahmed. 2000. Inoculation approach to legume
crops and their production assessment in Pakistan. A Review. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences,
32: 193-195.
Aubert, L. 1960. Arid
Zone soils, Study of Their Formation Characteristics, Utilization and
Conservation, in the problems of the Arid Zone. UNESCO Publications, Paris.
115-137.
Azmat, R.,
F. Naz, T. Khanum and A. Hayat. 2005. Persistent of pathogen in heavy metals
contaminated environment. Pakistan
Journal of Biological Sciences, 8(2): 235-238.
Barbara, S.,
K. Kathrin and P. Jorg. 2003. Alternate management on fens: Responses of
vegetation to grazing and mowing. Applied
Vegetation Science, 6: 245-254.
Bell,
J.N.B., A.J. Rutter and J. Relton. 1979. Studies on the effects of low levels
of sulphur dioxide on the growth of Lolium
perenne L. New Phytologist, 83:
1-7.
Bhatti,
M.A.R. 1999. Self sufficiency in food through soil improvement use of
bio-fertilizers. Pakistan Food and
Agriculture Review, 5: 12-14.
Birkeland,
P.W. 1984. Bulk Density Determination.
Soil and Geomorphology: Oxford University Press, New York,.14-15.
Bouyoucos,
G.J. 1962. Hydrometer method improved for making particle size analysis. Journal of Agronomy, 53: 464.
Chaudhary, I.I. 1961. The
vegetation of Karachi. Vegetatio, 10:
229-246.
Cottom, G.
and J.T. Curtis. 1956. The use of distance measure in phytosociological
sampling. Ecology, 37(3):
451-460.
Dueck, T.A.
and G.J. Endenijk. 1987. Soil pollution and changes in vegetation. Chamosphere, 16: 1021-1030.
Giblin,
A.E., A. Bourg, I. Valiela, and J.M. Teal. 1980. Uptake and losses of heavy
metals in sewage sludge by a New England salt marsh. American Journal of Botany, 67: 1059-1068.
Habib, I.
and M.Z. Iqbal 1996. Irrigation impact of rubber factory effluent on elemental
bioaccumulation and metabolite concentration in component parts of Triticum aestivum var. UP-262. Scientific Sindh, 3: 59-71.
Haghiri, F. 1973. Cadmium
uptake by plants. Journal of
Environmental Quality, 2: 93-96.
Iqbal, M.Z.
and F. Khalid. 1997. Effects of polluted soil extracts on germination and
seedling growth of some tree species. Polish
Journal of Environmental studies, 6: 25-28.
Iqbal, M.Z.
and M. Shafiq. 1996. Plant communities
on the sandy areas of Karachi University Campus. Journal of Islamic Academy of Sciences, 9(3): 89-98.
Iqbal, M.Z.
and S.A. Qadir. 1974. Observations on the plant communities of polluted
industrial drainage channels of Karachi, Pakistan. Environmental Pollution, 7: 253-257.
Iqbal, M.Z.,
M. Shafiq and S. Saeeda. 2001. Effects of cement dust on the growth of Albizia lebbeck and Dodonaea viscose. Ecological
Society (ECOS), 478-482.
Iqbal, M.Z.
1988. Accumulation of sulfur in foliage of roadside plantation and soil in
Karachi city. Ecology, 29: 1-5.
Jackson, M.L. 1958. Soil Chemical Analysis. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, pp. 408.
Keen, B.A.
1931. The Physical Properties of Soil.
New York: Longman Greenand Company, pp.380.
Ladha, J.K.,
M.G. Kandu, A. Coppenolle, M.B. Peoples and P.J. Dart. 1996. Legume
productivity and soil nitrogen dynamics in lowland rice based cropping systems.
Soil Science Society of America Journal,
60: 183-192.
Markert, B.
1990. Elements concentrations cadasters
in Ecosystem. VCH, Federal Republic of Germany, pp. 448.
Nelson, D.W.
and L.E. Sommers. 1996. Total carbon, organic carbon and organic matter. In: Methods of soil analysis, part 2, 2nd
(Ed.): A.L. Page et al., Agronomy.
9:961-1010. American Society of Agronomy. Incorporation Madison, WI.
Naheed, S.,
N. Ariz and S. Baig. 1986. Studies of particulate air pollutants in the
vicinity of a cement factory and its health hazards. Pakistan Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research, 29(4):
95-102.
Prodgers,
R.A. and W.P. Inskeep. 1981. Heavy metal tolerance of inland salt grass
Distichlis spicata. Great Basin
Naturalist, 51: 271-278.
Qadir, S.A.,
S.Z. Qureshi and M.A. Ahmed. 1966. A phytosociological survey of the Karachi
University Campus. Vegetatio, 13:
339-362.
Richard,
L.A. 1954. United States Lab. Staff Agricultural
Handbook No. 60, United State Department of Agriculture, pp. 129.
Shafiq, M.,
M.Z. Iqbal and I. Habib. 1992. Phytosociological studies around the industrial
areas of Landhi, Karachi, Pakistan. New
Agriculturist, 3: 179-188.
Singh, A.P.
1986. Seasonal fluctuation of organic matter with relation to moisture
retention characteristics and availability of water in salt effected soil
(India) Acta Botanica Indica, 14:
73-76.
Suntornvongsagul,
K., D.J. Burke, E.P. Hamerlynck and D. Hahn.
2007. Fate and effects of heavy metals in salt marsh sediments. Environmental Pollution, 149: 79-91.
Uzair, M.,
M. Ahmed and K. Nazim. 2009. Effect of
industrial waste on seed bank and growth of wild plant in Dhabeji area, Pakistan Journal of Botany, 41(4):
1659-1665.
William,
T.P, J.M. Bubb and J.N. Lester. 1994. Metal accumulation within salt marsh
environments: A review. Marine Pollution
Bulletin, 28: 277-290.
Windham, L.,
J.S. Weis and P. Weis. 2001. Patterns and processes of mercury release from
leaves of two dominant salt marsh macrophytes, Phragmites australis and Spartina
alterniflora. Estuaries, 24:
787-795.
Zaman, Q.U.
and M.Z. Iqbal. 1994. Vegetation pattern along the sewage effluents channels of
Malir river (Karachi). Turkish Journal of
Botany, 18: 425-430.
Zia, M.S.,
M.B. Baig and M.B. Tahir. 1998. Soil environment issues and their impact on
agricultural productivity of high potential area of Pakistan. Science Vision, 4: 56-61.
(Received for publication 16 September 2009)